When "Knowing that You Know" Isn't Enough: Certainty vs. Doubt
In this episode, we explore the heavy weight of certainty-based faith. For many of us, growing up in the church meant an emphasis on apologetics, debates, and having a "neatly tied bow" for every difficult question. But what happens when life hits—when suffering, loss, or intellectual questions arise—and that demand for 100% certainty begins to feel less like a foundation and more like a prison?
We dive into the "shaking" realization that certainty and faith are not actually the same thing. By looking at the Great Commission in Matthew 28, we find a startling truth: among the disciples who stood before the risen Jesus, "some doubted." And yet, Jesus didn't shame them—He commissioned them.
In this episode, we discuss:
The tension between high-pressure apologetics and the mystery of God.
How a "fear-based" pursuit of certainty can lead to isolation and deconstruction.
The difference between intellectual reasoning and biblical pistis (faith).
Learning to hold the "both/and" tensions of scripture without needing an immediate answer.
Why the Great Commission includes the doubters, not just the certain.
If you’ve ever been afraid of "being caught not knowing," this conversation is a permission slip to breathe, ask questions, and find God in the mystery.
Key Scriptures Mentioned:
Matthew 28:16-20: The Great Commission and the disciples who doubted.
Hebrews 11:1: Defining faith as assurance, not just physical proof.
Ephesians 2:8: Faith as a gift from God.
John 6:44: The Father’s role in drawing us to Himself.
Mentioned in the Episode:
From Genesis to Junia x Preston Sprinkle
Deconstruction Episode